SIGN IN YOUR ACCOUNT TO HAVE ACCESS TO DIFFERENT FEATURES

FORGOT YOUR PASSWORD?

FORGOT YOUR DETAILS?

AAH, WAIT, I REMEMBER NOW!

Sidelines MagazineSidelines Magazine

  • LOGIN
  • Home
  • Current Issue
  • Subscriptions
    • Flipbook
    • Subscribe Options
    • Order Individual & Back Issues
  • Podcast
  • Marketplace
    • Business Ads
    • Directories
      • Barns, Farms, Trainers & Clubs
      • Equestrian Services
      • Real Estate
      • Stallions
      • Tack & Feed Stores
    • Classifieds
    • Horse Trailers for Sale
  • Advertise
  • Blogs
    • Show World
    • What’s Happenin’
  • Partners
  • Contacts
    • Contacts
    • Employment
0
Monday, February 25 2019 / Published in General

Selling Your Horse Farm Business

Peter Shanahan

By Peter Shanahan, CFP, CRPC, MPAS

Naturally, when it comes time to sell a business — whether it be a widget factory or a horse farm — we want to sell for as much as possible. But simply getting the largest dollar sum for the sale may not be the best way to maximize your value. Here’s an example:

Fred built his farm over several decades. He added barns, outbuildings, a covered ring and loads of equipment. When it was time to sell, he naturally wanted the largest dollar sum the market would bear. When he negotiated the final $2.9 million price with his buyer, which included a $500,000 note, he was happy, and so was the buyer. Unfortunately, they both missed a few opportunities to maximize value by saving taxes.

Fred found out from his accountant that the barns, sheds and equipment he had been depreciating were subject to “recapture.” This meant that the tax rate on the “recaptured” depreciation would be much higher than the usual 20 percent capital gain tax rate. As a result, he ended up paying an extra 17 percent tax on the last half million. Cost: $85,000.

Fred was able to avoid paying taxes on the gain on the sale of his personal residence, which was on the property, and that was good for him. But what Fred wasn’t thinking about was his buyer. Fred’s buyer intended to use the rest of the farm as Fred had: as a business. That meant that he was going to use cash flow from the business to finance the note. The terms of the note were 10 years at 5 percent, payable monthly, with a payment amount of roughly $5,300 per month. But the buyer needed to earn over $7,500 before tax each month to make the $5,300 payment. Then, when Fred got the money, much of it was taxable to him as gain (much of which was taxed as “recapture” of depreciation), and some was taxed as interest on the note. In the end, Fred only ended up with about $4,500. So, Fred’s buyer needed to earn $7,500 just to get $4,500 into Fred’s hands. That’s $3,000 per month lost to taxes! That’s because the way Fred structured the sale, his buyer was able to deduct the interest portion of roughly $136,000 over the life of the loan, but not the $500,000 of principal. What a tremendous lost opportunity!

What could Fred have done to shelter some of the gain from taxes and to have some of the note payments taxed at a reduced rate?

This is a job for Fred’s team. He would need to involve his CPA, attorney and financial advisor. First, Fred could have looked into a strategy to help him defer tax on the sale of the business assets (the working farm; not the residence, which would need to be deeded separately. Fred’s attorney would do this after consulting with Fred’s CPA). A section 1031 tax free exchange is one way. The problem is that it’s messy. He would have needed to identify property to be exchanged prior to selling his farm, and he would have needed to close on the property within 180 days of the date his farm sale closed. But what if there was no suitable property at that time; what if the price of the property he identified to buy didn’t match the price of the farm he was selling; and what if the deal fell through at the last minute? And what if Fred didn’t want to own and manage another business property — he wanted out? What Fred might have done in this case is a commercial 1031 exchange for shares of a Delaware Statutory Trust established for this purpose. His financial advisor would facilitate this after consulting with Fred’s CPA. He could choose to do this for all or any portion of the sale price of business real estate (but again, not the residence). The rest would come to him as cash.

The portion of the sale price financed by the note would not be eligible for this exchange. But Fred could get a bit creative here, too. As for the problem of the note payments being paid with after-tax dollars from the buyer, and then taxable to Fred, he might have negotiated a consulting agreement with the buyer. He might have lowered the sale price and reduced the note — say by $100,000. The seller’s note payment would thereby be reduced by $1,060 per month, but that $1,060 would become Fred’s consulting fee. The buyer could then deduct that expense, and so use pre-tax dollars for this portion of the purchase price.

The consulting fee Fred would receive would, of course, be taxable to him as ordinary income rather than capital gain; but then, Fred might be able to deduct expenses like his car and professional equipment, as well as travel and, possibly, the cost of his home office. Fred might also invest a significant portion of the consulting fee in a pre-tax retirement plan. He would still have FICA taxes to pay, but he might still find that his net proceeds increased by a meaningful amount. Not to mention that when Fred was negotiating with his buyer, the two of them might have agreed to split the tax savings, reducing the net cost to the buyer while increasing the net benefit to Fred.

Fred also has a significant investment in depreciated equipment — let’s say $200,000. Rather than sell it as part of the farm sale, forcing him to pay ordinary tax rates on the recapture, and forcing his buyer to finance the purchase with after-tax dollars, Fred might consider leasing the equipment to his buyer. This would allow his buyer to have a clean paper trail to deduct the lease expense, and it would allow Fred to get an income stream based on the total value of the equipment, rather than on the net after-tax value.

These strategies are by no means a definitive list. The point here is that the sale of your horse farm business may offer a variety of opportunities that aren’t immediately visible and that you could easily miss — particularly if all you’re looking to do is maximize that one number, the sale price. On the other hand, if you’re willing to take some time, to involve your team early in the process and to think outside the box, you might find that there are any number of ways to improve the outcome, both to you and to your buyer. Sometimes the problem is, indeed, the way we look at the problem.

Peter Shanahan is a graduate of the College of William and Mary, a Certified Financial Planner and Chartered Retirement Planning Counselor. Peter has also earned the distinguished designation Master Planner Advanced Studies (MPAS). He is one of the founding partners of a wealth management practice with Hilliard Lyons in Hendersonville, North Carolina. He has been in practice for over 30 years, and has contributed to the training of hundreds of financial advisors. Peter owns a horse farm near Tryon, North Carolina,  ) and has earned colors with two local hunts, having served as treasurer for one of them. He also currently serves as president of a local equestrian trail association. He has lectured extensively on a variety of financial topics, but his primary area of interest is the intersection between his two passions: financial planning and equestrian pursuits.

Share this page:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)
Tagged under: horse cents, Peter Shanahan

What you can read next

Foto Friday! xx
roving Versatility Coast to Coast – Valerie Ashker Took Her Passion For OTTBs On The Road With A 3,300 Mile Journey
Season Winding Down

Download Sidelines Digital now from your favorite app store!

Sidelines Magazine - Apple store   Sidelines Magazine - Google Play store   Sidelines Magazine - Amazon store
Update iOS app. Re-download Google Play and Amazon app.

Follow on Instagram!

sidelines_magazine

Sidelines Magazine
Unbridled with Joe Norick! 🐎 Joe Norick stays Unbridled with Joe Norick! 🐎 Joe Norick stays busy with not one but two full-time jobs with companies that span the nation. The first is as a senior vice president for equine, farm and ranch clients with Alliant in West Palm Beach; the second, which he took on in October of 2022, is as the chief customer officer for HITS Shows. But Joe doesn’t care about titles. “I more consider myself the architect of what we’re creating here in the new HITS,” he said. Along with CEO Peter Englehart, Joe oversees all HITS Shows across the country—which is why he says lately it feels as though his home base has been American Airlines, traveling to each of the six unique HITS venues. “I love the fact that in Ocala we have so many beautiful paddocks, and over 500 acres that you can ride on and the horse can be a horse, and a horseman can be a horseman,” Joe said. “I love the beauty and charm that we have at our Chicago facility. I love the family aspect of Vermont. I love the high level of competition we have at both Del Mar and Saugerties, which we now call HITS Hudson Valley because of the amazing Hudson Valley. I love the tradition that we have in Virginia at our Culpepper facility. They all have something special.” Get to know Joe in this month's edition of Sidelines Magazine! and never miss an unbridled by subscribing for just $14.95 A YEAR! Link in bio! 📸Photo by ESI
Growing up, Zayna Rizvi put fashion ahead of funct Growing up, Zayna Rizvi put fashion ahead of function when it came to her riding attire. “I would only ride my first pony, Buttons, in a princess outfit. I refused to wear regular riding clothes and only wanted to ride in my tutu,” she said. The 2021 Maclay Finals winner has since shed her tutu and these days can be found sporting breeches and boots as she tackles the jumper ring in the High Juniors, U25 series, the FEI classes in the two-star and three-star divisions and occasionally makes her way back into some equitation classes. Immersed in the equestrian life from the start, Zayna can be found, if she isn’t doing schoolwork, in the barn trying to refine her riding as she aims to move up the ranks in international competitions. To read more about Zayna head on over to our website. Link in bio! 📸Portraits by Melissa Fuller
Check out Biostar US for innovative supplements to Check out Biostar US for innovative supplements to support your horse’s gut health! With specific plants found in old English hedgerows, Hedgerow GI supports GI tract homeostasis, microbes, immune cells, metabolites, and the tight junctions of the gut. This exclusive blend provides dimensional support for gut homeostasis. ⏩Link: https://www.biostarus.com/products/hedgerow-gi #biostarus #wholefoodforhorses #horses #equestrians #horsecare #equinehealth #hedgerowgi #hedgerows #horseguthealth #horsesupplements
Olivia Williams, who started her riding career in Olivia Williams, who started her riding career in a town with a population of less than 200 people, has now competed at some of the top equestrian destinations all over the country. A sophomore in college, she grew up in San Francisco where she spent the majority of her career riding with Holly and Elizabeth “Lumpy” Kilham at Kilham farms in Nicasio, California. She competed up and down the West Coast, showing everywhere from Desert International Horse Park to the Silicon Valley Equestrian Festival. While living in San Francisco, she got the ride on Irocco Blue S, barn name Rocco. Little did she know at the time that she and the 10-year-old Dutch Warmblood would travel the country together. Olivia and Rocco’s partnership has grown over the years, and she said that no matter where her career takes her, she can’t envision going into the ring without him. When they first met, Rocco and Olivia were both a little green and still learning the ropes of the 1.40m classes.But just a few years after Olivia starting riding Rocco, they now boast an impressive resume together, including competing in the North American Youth Championships (NAYC) and finishing 10th in the Prix des States. At the NAYC, Olivia’s team finished with a bronze medal, and she finished in sixth place individually. After the championships, Olivia had a lot of decisions to make. She graduated from high school in 2022 and had to decide between two very different life paths: a career in horses or a college education. She managed to find a path that has worked for her throughout her freshman year. While she moved away from home to go to the University of Notre Dame in Indiana, Rocco moved to Florida to live with Andrew and Alex Welles. Every other week, Olivia flies to Florida to compete her horse. Dying to read more??? Head on over to our website. Link in bio! 📸Photos by Melissa Fuller, melissafullerphotography33.mypixieset.com #Sidelines #sidelines2023 #sidelinesmagazine #magazine #forhorsepeople #abouthorsepeople
Load More... Follow on Instagram

From Our Classifieds Ads

  • BARN AND STALL RENTALS 2022-2023 SEASON
    - 6 STALLS w/apt & ring – SADDLE TRAIL - 5 STALLS w/apt & arena – SADDLE TRAIL - 4 STALLS – PADDOCK PARK - 6 STALLS w/arena and apt - SADDLE TRAIL Holly Ann Chaney • Douglas Elliman C: 561-719-0828 hollychaneygroup@gmail.com hollychaneygroup.com RENT EARLY, MANY MORE TO CHOOSE FROM THIS SEASON,

    [Read more]

  • MATT JOHNSON
    Farms & Estates ENGEL & VÖLKERS, Florida Serving Wellington since 1998 561-313-4367; wwwMattsells.com

    [Read more]

Sidelines Articles by Email

Subscribe to Sidelines Magazine Articles by Email

RSS Sidelines Blogs: What’s Happenin’

  • Woodside Recognizes the Best in the West
  • Get More for Your Money with an Adjustable-Rate Mortgage
  • Longines Global Champions Tour of New York Returns to Governors Island

RSS Sidelines Blogs: Show World

  • Conor Swail Was the Best Bet in $15,000 CSI2* Markel Insurance Welcome at San Juan Capistrano International
  • Lillie Keenan Leads in CHF68,000 South Coast Plaza Welcome Speed at San Juan Capistrano International CSIO5*
  • McLain Ward Wins CSIO5* Longines Grand Prix at San Juan Capistrano International

Category

Recent Posts

  • Zayna Rizvi: Horses from Family to Finals

    By Laura Scaletti Portraits by Melissa Fuller &...
  • Samantha Wolfram: Finding Success in America and Overseas

    By Juliana Chapman Portraits by Kirsten Hannah ...
  • Cedar Potts-Warner: At Liberty and Beyond

    Story and Portraits by Jennifer DeMaro   P...
  • Jordan Melfi: Turning a Secret Horse Life Into a Career

    By Veronica Green-Gott Portraits by Shelly Cart...
  • Olivia Williams: From University of Notre Dame to European Dreamin’

    By Veronica Green-Gott Portraits by Melissa Ful...

Copyright © 1987 - 2021 Sidelines Magazine
Privacy Policy · Returns & Refunds Policy · Hosting by Lucian Web Service
· Login

TOP
Get the Sidelines Scoop — your weekly look behind the scenes.Sign me up!